top of page

Eurovision Asia censorship highlights risks and opportunities of global expansion

Writer: Dale Roberts
Dale Roberts
9 hours ago
5 min read
Filipino spokesperson Vice Ganda was censored by Malaysian TV (Image: EBU/Voxovation)
Filipino spokesperson Vice Ganda was censored by Malaysian TV (Image: EBU/Voxovation)

Malaysia’s Eurovision Asia censorship controversy has raised questions about how the Contest can grow globally while staying true to its values.


Taking the Eurovision Song Contest global offers enormous opportunities, but it also comes with risks.


This was evident when Malaysian broadcaster TV3 appeared to censor LGBTQ+ representation during the inaugural Eurovision Asia, raising questions about how Eurovision can protect its values as it expands into regions with different laws and cultural attitudes.


The controversy comes after a promising debut for Eurovision Asia, which attracted worldwide media attention and encouraging early viewing figures.


A promising start for Eurovision Asia



The inaugural contest brought together 11 countries in Bangkok, with artists performing in a range of languages and styles, culminating in victory for the Philippines' Carmelle with Sobra-Sobra.


The event attracted considerable international attention, with coverage from major outlets including the BBC, The New York Times, Associated Press and The Guardian, alongside mainstream media throughout Asia.


Early television ratings have provided some encouragement, with the contest reaching more than five million viewers in Vietnam, including an average audience of just over one million on VTV3.


Further viewing figures are still to come, while organisers have also reported votes from 183 countries and territories.


For a fledgling competition, these are encouraging early signs, particularly given the challenges of establishing a new event in a region with vastly different music markets and audiences.


Malaysia highlights the challenges



However, just days after the inaugural contest, Eurovision Asia was making headlines around the world for a very different reason.


Footage circulating online appeared to show Malaysian broadcaster TV3 censoring LGBTQ+ representation during Eurovision Asia, including Filipino jury spokesperson Vice Ganda, one of the Philippines' biggest television stars who is openly gay and identifies as non-binary.


Additionally, shots of Thai drag performers during the opening number were replaced with footage that made them far less visible.


The censorship attracted international attention, including a report in The Guardian, which sought responses from Eurovision organisers.


Eurovision Song Contest Director Martin Green told The Guardian the EBU was "surprised and disappointed" that the Malaysian broadcast had been altered.


“We take this matter seriously and will be writing to Voxovation, the producers of the show, to seek clarification and ask them to establish with Malaysian broadcaster TV3 why this happened."

“This appears to be isolated to the Malaysian broadcast of the show, and all other transmissions were not altered.”


Martin Green (middle) and Christer Bjorkman (second from left) in Bangkok
Martin Green (middle) and Christer Bjorkman (second from left) in Bangkok

Voxovation also responded, saying it was investigating the circumstances and adding: "We are working with the Malaysian broadcaster to make sure this doesn’t happen again."


However, neither organisation has clarified whether broadcasters are contractually required to air the contest unedited or what consequences might follow.


The controversy highlights the challenges of taking Eurovision into markets where laws and attitudes towards LGBTQ+ representation can differ significantly from those in much of Europe.


In Malaysia, certain same-sex sexual acts are criminalised, with penalties of up to 20 years in prison, while LGBTQ+ representation in entertainment faces significant restrictions.


Bangladesh, another participating country, also criminalises same-sex sexual activity, although laws and attitudes vary considerably across Asia, including Thailand, which introduced marriage equality in 2025.


These challenges were foreseeable, with the EBU telling The Guardian before the contest that Eurovision's values were "non-negotiable".


Martin Green on protecting the Eurovision brand



In an interview with Aussievision shortly before the inaugural Eurovision Asia, we asked Martin Green how the organisation could protect Eurovision's values as the brand expanded into other regions.


Martin said the Eurovision team remained closely involved in international editions rather than simply licensing the brand and leaving others to run the competition.


"We are absolutely on top of it not only from the brand point of view and the competition point of view, but also from making sure that it lives up to the values and the reason why we all love the Eurovision Song Contest," Martin said.


He also revealed that protecting those values was written into contracts with partners.


"Contracts are not just about money, right? Contracts are about respecting values and the way we deliver things."


"We're as fiercely contractual about our values as we are about our rules," he added.


Martin also emphasised the importance of working with partners who shared Eurovision's values and genuinely cared about the competition.


"So we check it at every every step," he said.


But the censorship in Malaysia has now put those commitments to the test.


The EBU has previously taken strong action over censorship, terminating its partnership with Chinese streaming service Mango TV in 2018 after it removed performances and censored LGBTQ+ imagery during the European contest.


However, Eurovision Asia operates through a licensing arrangement with Voxovation rather than directly under the EBU's management, creating an additional layer between Eurovision's brand owners and participating broadcasters.


And there is another important difference between the two competitions.


Eurovision needs Asia, but does Asia need Eurovision?



At this early stage, Eurovision and Voxovation arguably need Asia more than Asia needs Eurovision.


After nearly two decades of attempts, the competition has finally launched, and organisers need to retain participating broadcasters while attracting more to make the event sustainable.


Unlike Europe, where Eurovision has decades of history and established relationships, the competition has little history or influence in Asia, where many countries already have thriving music industries and major entertainment formats.


This creates a different power dynamic, with organisers potentially having more to lose by taking a hard line against broadcasters.


There are also cultural considerations in how business relationships and disagreements are handled across the region.


In many Asian business environments, maintaining relationships, respecting hierarchy and avoiding a public loss of face can be particularly important.


Publicly reprimanding or threatening a broadcaster could damage those relationships and make future cooperation more difficult, even if the criticism itself is justified.


But taking a softer approach brings its own risks, particularly if Eurovision's existing audience sees it as compromising the values that have become central to the brand.


While resolving disputes privately may sometimes be more effective, organisers still need to demonstrate that their commitments carry consequences.


The challenge is that taking a strong stance could cost Eurovision the broadcasters it needs to succeed in Asia, while failing to do so could damage its reputation in Europe.


Where does Eurovision go from here?


The Malaysian controversy is unlikely to be the last challenge Eurovision faces as it expands internationally.


With other regions, including the Arab world and Latin America, already being explored, there are enormous opportunities for growth alongside further cultural and political challenges.


The inaugural Eurovision Asia has shown promising signs that the brand can succeed beyond Europe, and it would be unfortunate for those achievements to be overshadowed entirely by one controversy.


But future expansion will inevitably bring difficult decisions about how far Eurovision can adapt to local circumstances without compromising its values.


Ultimately, protecting those values may mean accepting that some broadcasters and markets will not be willing to participate, even if that comes at the expense of Eurovision's global ambitions.


For continued updates on all Eurovision Song Contest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, TikTok, YouTube, BlueSky, Threads and Instagram: https://linktr.ee/aussievisionnet

 
 
bottom of page